Kirill N Posted September 30, 2015 Posted September 30, 2015 This was a great feature in 3.x. I remember it was going to be added to 4.0 and it was in the Release Notes but I haven't heard anything about it in months. Is it still coming back? prupdated, AlexJ, sobrenome and 5 others 8
Kirill N Posted October 22, 2015 Author Posted October 22, 2015 Would be nice to get an update on this. This was a very useful feature. prupdated, chilihead and Haku2 3
Adriano Faria Posted October 22, 2015 Posted October 22, 2015 It was requested during the 4.0.0 preview/Beta. They said it would come back, someday. 4.2 who knows. sobrenome and prupdated 2
prupdated Posted December 4, 2015 Posted December 4, 2015 This should really move up the priority list. I have a forum with nearly 4 million posts and 600k topics. In IPB3, the size of the forums didn't seem to matter. In IPB 4, the site chokes up and delays about 2-3 seconds every time someone would click on a forum with a large number of topics in it. By large, I mean several hundred thousand topics and millions of posts. Clicking on a smaller forum is no problem and happens fast. This is a 12 core server with 32 GB of RAM running at 3.2 GHz, MariaDB, etc. and various optimizations, CDN, etc. The only way I could even use IPB4 without reverting back to IPB 3 and reconsidering my alternatives, was to chop up the forums into smaller ones. The main forum being about 50k topics max. Most likely the way I do it is not the best through various SQL statements. But to keep the site moving with sub second load times, I push out topics over 90 days old into an annual forum. I know there's an archive option, but the last time I tried that I didn't like that it took those topics out of searches and member's history. I'd rather just have an option to move topics to another forum after X days without the archiving. sobrenome 1
Morrigan Posted December 4, 2015 Posted December 4, 2015 For @prupdated I could recommend you use the archive feature and store your archived posts in a separate database than your more recent stuff. I think it would likely improve your load times. AndyF and sobrenome 2
AndyF Posted December 4, 2015 Posted December 4, 2015 From what I understand it is possible it will make a comeback at some point with some additional protection, going from what I can recall reading when we had the 'upcoming' type features page. I also recall my and others suggestions that extra protection to it would be added as prune 'accident's are scary and quite upsetting to forum admins, more so the ones without a current backup available. Having seen this happen myself to a community, its not nice. I'm not sure what the protection is likely to be, I recall suggesting a re-authenticate (ie: you would have to confirm your password to use it) and possibly it may be restricted to those who have ACP access. sobrenome and Morrigan 2
prupdated Posted December 5, 2015 Posted December 5, 2015 16 hours ago, Morrigan said: For @prupdated I could recommend you use the archive feature and store your archived posts in a separate database than your more recent stuff. I think it would likely improve your load times. Thanks for the suggestion. I tried it before but search is lost on archived topics. Generally it would be a good idea except for the functionality loss. The load times now are fine while not losing the functionality when archiving. It was just the size of an individual forum that was the problem. Hence, moving topics could be a decent solution for this and other problems, maintenance, or many other reasons why one might want to bulk move. I've worked around it for now doing my best with SQL scripting to move older topics out of the main forum each night while updating the various related counters. Most likely I'm missing something though. So it would be nice to have an official routine.
Kevin Carwile Posted December 5, 2015 Posted December 5, 2015 9 hours ago, prupdated said: I've worked around it for now doing my best with SQL scripting to move older topics out of the main forum each night while updating the various related counters. Most likely I'm missing something though. You can automate routines with rules. Give me a buzz if you are interested.
Bill Edwards Posted December 8, 2015 Posted December 8, 2015 As my storage is limited, I had a Mod for 3.4 that pruned our topic list after a set period. It worked well for us. It's not a feature of 4.1 and I can't find a Mod for it. The only option I have at the moment is check every forum and manually delete topics over a certain age. I would love to see this feature built in!!
Keith Roberts Posted June 30, 2016 Posted June 30, 2016 This feature would be really helpful for our forum. Most of our sub forums were never pruned as members treat most of the posts as a resource to help with their interests but we do ahve a couple of areas where off topic content is permitted, and a simple pruning tool really would be a boon. sobrenome 1
greg185 Posted October 9, 2016 Posted October 9, 2016 +1 for this feature to return, really missing not being able to prune selected forums after 90 days of no replies etc... Keith Roberts and sobrenome 2
DanInMS Posted December 10, 2016 Posted December 10, 2016 Would like this to return as well. Keith Roberts 1
pilotguy Posted August 22, 2017 Posted August 22, 2017 On 12/5/2015 at 10:45 AM, Kevin Carwile said: You can automate routines with rules. Give me a buzz if you are interested. I have your rules apps... BUZZ I would like to be able to MOVE topics to a new forum based on the topic title or keyword search in the message body.
Jack M Posted May 7, 2018 Posted May 7, 2018 Any word on this? I need this. Old pictures are driving up my forum size and cost.
Aramaech Posted June 5, 2018 Posted June 5, 2018 (edited) Yes, yet another vote for this feature please. Kevin's Rules app is Great, but bulk moving topics as a means of just basic organization seems like a common sense feature that should just be built into the software. Edited June 5, 2018 by RobotMonkeyHæd
Kevin Carwile Posted June 5, 2018 Posted June 5, 2018 Create a custom action to use for your bulk move process. It will use a topic as an argument. Now add a rule to that custom action which moves the topic to the forum of your choice. Now schedule that rule to run in bulk for all your topics. Dont forget to add a condition to your rule so that you dont move every single topic on your site.
SJ77 Posted September 11, 2018 Posted September 11, 2018 On 9/30/2015 at 1:37 PM, Kirill N said: This was a great feature in 3.x. I remember it was going to be added to 4.0 and it was in the Release Notes but I haven't heard anything about it in months. Is it still coming back? I am shocked that there is still not per forum auto prune feature. I have a couple of specific forums that I want to auto prune after topics are 30 days old. Bill Edwards 1
Millipede Posted September 11, 2018 Posted September 11, 2018 Might this app be of use? Except it's "not currently available for purchase." You might want to check the support topic, as there currently seems to be a bug with it if it's set to ignore topics with replies. It's identical to a similar hook that used to exist for IPB 3, I think called Forum Pruner. AndyF and SJ77 2
Faqole Posted September 21, 2018 Posted September 21, 2018 On 9/11/2018 at 5:08 AM, SJ77 said: I am shocked that there is still not per forum auto prune feature. I have a couple of specific forums that I want to auto prune after topics are 30 days old. I have released a plugin that will do that. You can see it here AndyF 1
AndyF Posted September 21, 2018 Posted September 21, 2018 On 12/4/2015 at 7:07 PM, AndyF said: I recall suggesting a re-authenticate (ie: you would have to confirm your password to use it) and possibly it may be restricted to those who have ACP access. As this topic was replied to (with two useful third party tools) I think the above is still relevant for anything inbuilt if it appeared on the "front end" , prune is very handy and useful indeed *when used correctly and with care to be sure what you are doing* but as with the nature of the function itself, the scope for 'accidents' is present...
SJ77 Posted September 21, 2018 Posted September 21, 2018 This might not do exactly what I need. I need to set posts in specific forums to hide after a specific number of days from the ORIGINAL post (as opposed to the last reply). Less important but would be nice to have is number of days per forum instead of 1 setting for all. Then I can have one forum that hides posts after 3 days and another that hides posts after 30 days. Then I can sell access to these forums based on tiers. Thank you
Faqole Posted September 21, 2018 Posted September 21, 2018 3 hours ago, SJ77 said: This might not do exactly what I need. I need to set posts in specific forums to hide after a specific number of days from the ORIGINAL post (as opposed to the last reply). Less important but would be nice to have is number of days per forum instead of 1 setting for all. Then I can have one forum that hides posts after 3 days and another that hides posts after 30 days. Then I can sell access to these forums based on tiers. Thank you I can change the criteria from the last reply time to topic start date at my add on. It is a very small edit. Regarding adding the the number of days to the individual forums, I can add that too for a small fee.
Recommended Posts