Durango Posted June 30, 2015 Posted June 30, 2015 Hi There is a great feature on some large boards, often boards belonging to large companies They allow visitors to post and only at the end require username & email to perform the registration Many visitors would never register first and then post, they directly post with a form, and discover at the end they have to provide username & email to have their post submitted, so they accept to give those informations This is very powerful, and i was hoping to see this on IPS 4, maybe it is available and i didnt see it ? You must have seen this many times on the web, an example here on a french website : http://voyage.linternaute.com/forum/canada-24002/new
Durango Posted March 7, 2016 Author Posted March 7, 2016 Any new about this ? This would boost people participation to a board it would be a great feature for IPB
sobrenome Posted March 7, 2016 Posted March 7, 2016 On June 30, 2015 at 5:03 PM, Durango said: Hi There is a great feature on some large boards, often boards belonging to large companies They allow visitors to post and only at the end require username & email to perform the registration Many visitors would never register first and then post, they directly post with a form, and discover at the end they have to provide username & email to have their post submitted, so they accept to give those informations This is very powerful, and i was hoping to see this on IPS 4, maybe it is available and i didnt see it ? You must have seen this many times on the web, an example here on a french website : http://voyage.linternaute.com/forum/canada-24002/new Very interesting way to get more users!
sudo Posted March 7, 2016 Posted March 7, 2016 This would be a key feature for social engagement @Lindy If they sign up and dont get the registration email (given all the mandrill changes etc recently) it would be nice to have a modal with an option to contact an admin directly to help aid them become activated. This modal could also be used for new registrations without the post.
SammyS Posted March 7, 2016 Posted March 7, 2016 Interesting feature, dont know why it didnt get more feedback. That´s something Iwould like to get to my forum
chilihead Posted March 7, 2016 Posted March 7, 2016 Seems like a bait and switch tactic I would not use myself, it would frustrate me if I was on a site, took 20 minutes to compose a post that the system let me compose, to be hit with a register prompt. I'd say "screw this place" and close the window. Unless it was done for ease and a warning message told them something like "You will be taken to the registration form before this post is published." I don't like the idea of tricking people into registering but if there is full disclosure that they still need to register, then it could be a nice convenience.
Management Lindy Posted March 7, 2016 Management Posted March 7, 2016 We actually have something planned that should make you happy.
SammyS Posted March 7, 2016 Posted March 7, 2016 26 minutes ago, Lindy said: We actually have something planned that should make you happy. 4.2, I guess?
Durango Posted March 7, 2016 Author Posted March 7, 2016 5 hours ago, sobrenome said: Very interesting way to get more users! yes very powerfull ! Actually we used to have a forum with a home made script, and we had developped such a feature : basically the same than the link of my first post of this topic, well it has increased the participation a lot : we had around 30 new posts per day, versus 10-12 posts before, so almost *3 !! thats why this is the first feature i asked for when moving to IPB last year, but no reactions then 4 hours ago, ZeroHour said: This would be a key feature for social engagement @Lindy If they sign up and dont get the registration email (given all the mandrill changes etc recently) it would be nice to have a modal with an option to contact an admin directly to help aid them become activated. This modal could also be used for new registrations without the post. Tx ZeroJour 2 hours ago, SammyS said: Interesting feature, dont know why it didnt get more feedback. That´s something Iwould like to get to my forum Same here ! 1 hour ago, sobrenome said: Much better a built in feature. Agree ! 43 minutes ago, chilihead said: Seems like a bait and switch tactic I would not use myself, it would frustrate me if I was on a site, took 20 minutes to compose a post that the system let me compose, to be hit with a register prompt. I'd say "screw this place" and close the window. Actually it is not a bait, it is just an easier way to post for people, sometimes you have 2mn to post : type 3 lines then give an id & passwd & mail, and youre done, so easier than having to register first, go to your mail, validate the mail, go back to the forum, relogin, find again the place where you wanted to post etc etc : such a hassle ! look at the link i posted above : http://voyage.linternaute.com/forum/canada-24002/new there is no surprise for the user, he knows from the very beginning he will give an id & mail at then end of the form 41 minutes ago, Lindy said: We actually have something planned that should make you happy. Hi Lindy, so good to hear
chilihead Posted March 7, 2016 Posted March 7, 2016 2 minutes ago, Durango said: there is no surprise for the user, he knows from the very beginning he will give an id & mail at then end of the form I like the idea then. It sounded like you allow guest posting but then "bam" nope, we don't. I like the idea of post, submit, register, it is posted.
Durango Posted March 8, 2016 Author Posted March 8, 2016 Hi 15 hours ago, chilihead said: I like the idea then good to hear Here are screenshots made to show what could be done to boost people's engagement : Normal Reply if guest : Suggested Reply if guest : on the model of one of the main french sites (CCM) : http://www.commentcamarche.net/forum/linux-unix-13/new many other leading communities in the world are doing the same like Tomsguide (UK) : http://www.tomsguide.com/forum/ The idea is simple : you ask your question or you answer a topic first, then we ask you to register : very powerful to increase users engagement Of course this could be an option in the ACP easier to post a screenshot i know than actually coding it i know @Lindy any idea welcome
Omri Amos Posted May 5, 2016 Posted May 5, 2016 Great idea!! Just one more thing - don't forget that it's not only for "reply", but also for "post new topic" And in this regard, I would add that an option to "write first, choose later" is a great idea for choosing the right forum for the new topic as well... For example, I would have a BIG BUTTON (even on my homepage outside the forums) that says "HAVE A QUESTION? ASK IN OUR FORUM!" and will take the user to the "post new topic" page. After he enter his message (or on the same page, but not before he get the chance to write his post), he will be then asked to choose the most suitable forum for the subject of his topic. Right now I can't have this big button that will encourage people to post new topics, because before they can get to the "post new topic" page they HAVE to choose a forum first...
Durango Posted May 15, 2016 Author Posted May 15, 2016 excellent idea Omri Amos ! the idea of a great button "ASK YOUR QUESTION" is great
Kit_L Posted May 24, 2016 Posted May 24, 2016 That would work perfectly on my Home page too. Because of past spamming, I manually approve all new users, but I can see how I could combine the "Ask your question" idea with this (just have a display line "your post is being moderated" to cover the time it takes to send out an email to the new user, and get a valid reply email back then hand approve). This could definitely work for us. Great idea.
EricT Posted July 13, 2016 Posted July 13, 2016 On 07/03/2016 at 7:54 PM, Lindy said: We actually have something planned that should make you happy Is it still planned ? Do you think it will be available this year ? Thank you
Management Lindy Posted July 13, 2016 Management Posted July 13, 2016 55 minutes ago, EricT said: Is it still planned ? Do you think it will be available this year ? Thank you Yes... And I sure hope so!
Durango Posted July 15, 2016 Author Posted July 15, 2016 Tx @Lindy i cant wait to see it live that would totally change our participation rate and boost our communities people are so lazy they dont want to register even if they wanted to say something, having them saying what they want to say FIRST, and then ask them a username & email AFTER is the key
Omri Amos Posted July 16, 2016 Posted July 16, 2016 23 hours ago, Durango said: people are so lazy they dont want to register even if they wanted to say something, having them saying what they want to say FIRST, and then ask them a username & email AFTER is the key Totally agree. Also please don't forget my idea about letting then say what they want to say FIRST, and then ask them to *choose a forum* (which is another annoying step) AFTER...
sobrenome Posted July 16, 2016 Posted July 16, 2016 So anxious for this extremely engagement feature!
Omri Amos Posted September 19, 2016 Posted September 19, 2016 Please see how easy and fun it is to post a new topic in Discourse: All you have is a very straightforward form with the title, CATEGORY, and message. You can post a new topic from everywhere, you don't have to enter a specific forum ("category") and then use the "new topic" button from there... Discourse has many very good UX / UI advantages over all other traditional forum softwares, but it does lack on other things in the name of simplicity. I think that you should really consider adopting some of its concepts, such as making it much easier to post new topics.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.