I honestly can't decide whether this is good or bad news, I understand both point of views.
My 2 cts (definitely not worth more):
- I like the idea that devs will have more freedom, but the risk of security issue is real issue for me. Most of us do not have the money to perform professional security assessment of our sites. I liked the idea that ips reviewed proposed ressources.
- the centralized aspect of the marketplace was very simple for community owners, hopefully we will have a viable alternative.
- marketplace ressources and discussion is one of the main reason I come here, the impact on this community might be an issue.
Globally this looks like another step toward "big customers" who can pay for specific dev and further away from small community owners who try to improve their community for a few $.
What is surprising is that it looks like you invested in the marketplace not so long ago integrating it in the admincp and with the compatibility check etc...
Also I guess a big part of the costs is about resource checking which is something you implemented not so long ago and actually might explain part of the marketplace activity decrease one the devs part.
In the end, we will see how this goes but honestly the 3 months warning is clearly not enough and a change of this magnitude deserve better that an announce in the middle of the summer with a short warning.