Can someone confirm this on 4.3 or 4.3.1 ??

[SJ77]

This issue happens on 4.2, I want to know if it's fixed for 4.3

1. have userA create a paid file
2. Delete userA via ACP
3. Guest owns file formerly owned by userA
4. PROBLEM: Any Guest on earth can download paid file for FREE

[SJ77]

Please someone just take a moment to try this. I really need to know.

 

[Nathan Explosion]

Or test it yourself by creating a demo on IPS cloud?

[SJ77]

6 hours ago, Nathan Explosion said:

Or test it yourself by creating a demo on IPS cloud?

interesting idea. Had not crossed my mind.

However,.. this... Have a plan B ??

• Insert existing attachment

[Adriano Faria]

I’ll try tomorrow in the morning. 

[All Astronauts]

Gave this a run for you.

When you delete a member in 4.3 you get a few options. You can still display their name next to the content owned by them or flip it to guest. You can also choose to hide/delete all of their content as well.

I did the following:

Created user
Logged in as them.
Made a paid file.
Confirmed all is good with paid file, other users and guests had to pay/checkout.
Deleted user - chose to flip to Guest name and keep content.

Went back to the front end, logged in to another account, was still forced to pay/checkout the now Guest file.

Logged out and as a guest user I was also still forced to pay/checkout.

Now as to where any money goes during this transaction - I imagine it just stays with the "house" so to speak, as in if file is paid and owner is "guest" (or does not exist) then percentage of revenue for paid file is 100% site. Purely a logical guess, haven't looked.

 

[Adriano Faria]

3 minutes ago, All Astronauts said:

Logged out and as a guest user I was also still forced to pay/checkout.

If you allow guests to download files (category permission), then any guest will download it for free. 

[All Astronauts]

Yes, that's a universal group permission to allow (I guess) admins to check over files and the like for content.

Can download paid files without paying?

I don't think anyone would ever choose to set that to "yes" for guests...

[Adriano Faria]

Even if you set it to NO, guests will download.

That’s the bug. 

[All Astronauts]

And... that doesn't happen on 4.3, which is what I was confirming.

Quote

Logged out and as a guest user I was also still forced to pay/checkout.

Guest user on a paid file "owned" by Guest has to pay for the file on 4.3.

If you want to be picky, you could report a bug since setting that can download paid files without paying setting does not affect anything for Guests on 4.3. Toggled on or off Guests have to pay for paid files; which is actually a good thing.

[Adriano Faria]

Still happening on 4.3.1:

Category permission allows guests to download files:

Can download paid files without paying? is disabled for guests but they still can download paid files without pay.

That's the buy I mentioned.

@SJ77, did you report this as you said you would?

[SJ77]

I did report it and they said it was fixed in 4.3.1 which is why I was asking.