v3 Suggestion - Undisposable

[Bluedeep]

With 2.3.6, we use recaptcha now.

But... why don't implement also undisposable?

http://undisposable.net/

Thank you

[Jaggi]

anyone could just report a email to that list its not really accurate.

[Amy T]

anyone could just report a email to that list its not really accurate.

Yep I agree.
If you do not want members using disposable emails just blocked them using the ban filter.

[W13]

Useless feature.

(And I'd rather not have IPB depend on too much other stuff)

[Amy T]

Useless feature.

(And I'd rather not have IPB depend on too much other stuff)

Ditto.
I think the OP should just use the ban list to ban disposable emails.

[Bluedeep]

Have you idea, how many new disposable domain are created every day?

Undisposable use the same system of DNSBL, a collaborative system of feedback...

Every feedback is checked before flag it...

Truly speaking, are three lines of code, and who wouldn't use it, is enough swich off on the admin panel.

Bye

[Deltafox]

I believe both a good idea, and each has the right to express it... it depends then on the staff ipb to decide.. Regards

[Morrigan]

I believe both a good idea, and each has the right to express it... it depends then on the staff ipb to decide.. Regards

IPB considers all suggestions but they also consider the majority of the customer response as well. I personally wouldn't want this.

[Amy T]

ya I do not want it either.
I use gmail as my primary email and gmail is now considered a disposable email.

[Cool Surfer]

With 2.3.6, we use recaptcha now.

But... why don't implement also undisposable?

http://undisposable.net/

Thank you

So it basically tell u if the email id exists or not ?

I am sure bot programmers are smart guys, they can have a script to auto generate valid email ids too
before the request goes to undisposable.

[Bluedeep]

ya I do not want it either.

I use gmail as my primary email and gmail is now considered a disposable email.

Is impossible.

Gmail is not a disposable email.

So it basically tell u if the email id exists or not ?

I am sure bot programmers are smart guys, they can have a script to auto generate valid email ids too

before the request goes to undisposable.

It doesn't check if an emails it exists or not
is a collaborative protection system against disposable email addressing (DEA).

If is collaborative, yes: if script kiddie makes a new undisposable email it could pass some time before that email will be add to the blacklist...

But each blacklist works as is.

--

The question is could be usefull? My answer is yes. People who wouldn't use it, could always turn off it, don't?

[sunrisecc]

Gmail is not a disposable email.

Any mail account that one could obtain without paying for it is 'disposable' for me. Such email accounts are only slightly above the pure throw-away email address.

[Bluedeep]

Any mail account that one could obtain without paying for it is 'disposable' for me. Such email accounts are only slightly above the pure throw-away email address.

Gmail could be used as disposable, but providers as jetable.org and pookmail certainly disposable.

However, no one of the disposable blacklist consider gmail (or yahoo, msn, ecc...) as disposable :)

[bfarber]

Gmail could be used as disposable, but providers as jetable.org and pookmail certainly disposable.

However, no one of the disposable blacklist consider gmail (or yahoo, msn, ecc...) as disposable :)

Then I don't see how much good it would do, as 50-80% (at least here) of the recent spammings came from a @gmail.com email address account.

[Bluedeep]

Then I don't see how much good it would do, as 50-80% (at least here) of the recent spammings came from a @gmail.com email address account.

Yeah, but the point is to fight users who use disposable account.

If an email exist few minutes, then why require email validation during the registration?

My two cents ;)

[W13]

Yeah, but the point is to fight users who use disposable account.

If an email exist few minutes, then why require email validation during the registration?

My two cents ;)

It takes a Chinese email farmer like 20 seconds to register a new gmail account. (probably less time than it takes to register on IPB)