Bug in Group Promotion or wrong logic?

[Cyboman]

I have a group promotion rule, that members whose last post is older than 365 days AND last visit is older than 365 days will be moved to a special "deactivation group".

So, if I create a new member account for a new user in the ACP, and configure this account to be in the "regular membergroup" primary member group, he will immediately be moved to the "deactivation group".

Means: NEW MEMBERS == LAST POST > 365 days OR LAST VISIT > 365 days?

I think, the last posting activity or last visit activity shouldn't be honored for new accounts, that never had a valid login nor any action.

Am I right or am I missing something?

[bfarber]

For a new member, there is no last post or last visit (so they qualify as > __any__ days ago). You should add a joined filter to your rule as well for this scenario.