Instead of that Popup, can the Emoticons in the Fast Reply View please be a Javascript Maxmize/minimize thing, a bit like the fast Reply itself. Anyone Agree?

I think if someone tried, they could make it where some smiles showed up on one side, and the rest on the other. But as Matt said...
"Its a FAST reply"

Nick

(Plus, you can program the smilies to simple, rememberable codes)

There is a mod on invisionize for this

That defeats the purpose.

Thier isnt anything Fast to my mind about that pop-up.

It's meant to be plain and simple. It's not a full reply box.
That pop-up comes up just as quickly as smilies would next to the message.

Yeah! And how about we place a member list inside the fast reply box, and the ability to edit your profile, hell lets put the whole board in the fast reply box!

Fast Reply, (n)- A small box designed for small and fast replys

Fast reply allows you to reply without loading another page, i.e. the reply page. I don't see how adding a smilie box defeats the purpose. Actually, it makes it even more convenient.

I made this reply with the fast reply box :thumbsup:

See, I used emoticons because I know the easy code used here. If you use easy codes such as thumbsup for the :thumbsup: icon, then there really is no need.

I believe this has also been suggested before.