Jump to content

Himadri Goswami

Clients
  • Posts

    187
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    Himadri Goswami reacted to LiquidFractal in New: Clubs   
    I see the point that Pages (as it currently stands) could be a bit complicated for non-Admins, but I do think that Clubs at some point needs the ability to create a more robust environment which doesn't necessarily have to be a "mini website" (although I'm not sure how blocks would function without the concept of the page).  One could limit the amount of "pages" (let's call them pages for the sake of argument) a Club (or any Club) can have; one can charge a subscription fee to create a Club; or if one wanted to one could manage all the Clubs on one's site, depending on how many there are.
    It's really the issue of multiculturalism transferred to the idea of the website: how much do you want other Clubs/"cultures" to be able to articulate themselves on your site before there is a crisis of identity?  There is no one right answer of course, but I think it's better to have the tools for expansion than not.
    For me, the philosophical issue is that successful clubs will grow and evolve, and while one can control this growth like for example limiting pages or whatever, it isn't clear to me how blocks will cut it without the potential to narrativize one's Club content through, for example, consecutive pages (with or without blocks).  As I said, I agree that Pages on the Admin side is not for the beginner, but maybe there's an alternative for the Club owner side of things - in the future.
  2. Like
    Himadri Goswami reacted to Simon Woods in New: Clubs   
    Then you should avoid using it and wait.
  3. Like
    Himadri Goswami reacted to The Old Man in New: Clubs   
    I've changed my mind, I no longer think Clubs needs Pages with their databases etc, that's all a bit overkill.
    Too much like having members basically creating  mini websites for free that your server is powering and you are paying for to host, and they would suffer identify crisis with links and references to the host community. Plus Pages is too generic out of the box but more importantly over complicated for Admin's, never mind members who just want to type and post.
    However I do think it disappointing that there is still no built-in support to add simple rich text custom content/widget blocks to Forums, not only would Forums benefit hugely from custom content blocks that could be easily drag and dropped where you want them like widgets, but then Clubs would inherit the feature and it would give Club owners that bit of extra choice and customisation to easily make their Club stand out and look different to all the others (besides a header). 
    Then we could position ads  (inside the block) somewhere in the sidebar other than just the top slot of the side bar, without having to buy Commerce just to achieve that. You could also then quickly add or external/third party content like a Twitter feed, PHP or Jquery accordions, tabbed blocks, sliders etc.
    Pages provides that ability but limiting custom content blocks to Pages isn't the best idea or use of the system. They used to be Blogs years way back when.
    There again, I think Pages should be redisgned to a database solution and their should instead be a new much friendlier app created (or perhaps Blogs taken to the Wordpress pages level) for those who want a site home/webpage front end for their website with a range of news articles layouts to choose from out of the box and custom blocks like Wordpress has. This way Admin's would have the 2 sets of member registration databases and members could respond to news comments and post in forums, clubs, gallery etc.
    Clubs needs just the custom blocks aspect of Pages, at least I think for the majority.
  4. Like
    Himadri Goswami got a reaction from crmarks in New: Customizable Blog Sidebar   
    No, I meant a better page template similar to wiki on existing wiki style articles.  I have already achieved Table of contents etc by modifying html, but it is painful to do edit every post  

  5. Like
    Himadri Goswami got a reaction from LiquidFractal in New: Customizable Blog Sidebar   
    No, I meant a better page template similar to wiki on existing wiki style articles.  I have already achieved Table of contents etc by modifying html, but it is painful to do edit every post  

×
×
  • Create New...