HI,

I used to have a possibility to add comments to the positive and negative reputation at the given time.
The modification did however break a few other things (we now found were needed more) on the forum, so we had to remove it.

What happened in our forum after the comment-possibility was removed from the reputation system, was that we now get more posts with no or little content, more smileys and more single word posts. Not so very good for content :)

Would it be possible to add a comment-box when giving reputation as a new feature to the 3.1 version of IPB?

It won't be added in 3.1, since we're wrapping development on that version now. It is possible that we will add this feature in a later version, but we can't promise anything yet :)

OK, sounds fair.

Looking very much forward to the release of 3.1 though :)

If you post reporting the issue to the mod maker he might be able to fix the issues you had and make it workable for you in the mean time.